logo
  • News
    • Community
    • Local Government
    • Sports
    • Alberta Politics
    • Opinion
    • Deke
  • Events
  • Peaks & Valleys
    • Wildlife
    • Hiking and Climbing
    • Biking
    • Fishing
    • Snow Sports
  • Culture
    • Jasper Arts & Culture
    • Local Dining
    • Local Literature
  • Jasper History
  • Support
    • News
      • Community
      • Local Government
      • Sports
      • Alberta Politics
      • Opinion
      • Deke
    • Events
    • Peaks & Valleys
      • Wildlife
      • Hiking and Climbing
      • Biking
      • Fishing
      • Snow Sports
    • Culture
      • Jasper Arts & Culture
      • Local Dining
      • Local Literature
    • Jasper History
    • Support
The winning ingredients: Competition in nature
In the bird kingdom, songbirds will compete for territories and advertise their victory via their distinctive songs. // Mark Bradley - Boreal Nature Photography
Environment, News, Peaks & Valleys, Wildlife
By Mark Bradley, Freelance contributor
Thursday, June 27, 2024
The winning ingredients: Competition in nature

This is the time of year when competition is on everyone’s mind. 

The NHL and NBA playoffs have just ended, the 2024 Euros are underway and the Paris Olympics are just around the corner. Everywhere you look, people are straining and sweating to reach the podium or lift the cup (sadly, my Toronto Raptors failed to even reach the postseason this year).

In nature, however, competition is pretty much year round, and the stakes are much higher. We’re talking about survival! The ultimate goal of any animal is not to dominate the podium, but to have its genes represented in the next generation. Natural selection was first described by Charles Darwin in 1859 in his best-selling book On the Origin of Species. The basic idea is that in every generation, more young are born than will survive to breed in the next generation. Animals that are able to run, jump, forage, or fight better than their competitors will leave behind the most offspring, and thereby represent a larger proportion of the next generation. Genetic inheritance means that the next generation will be slightly better adapted to its surroundings. Over millions of years these the accumulation of these slight changes has resulted in the vast array of animals we see today. 

Take it one game at a time

Competition occurs whenever two or more animals struggle to gather for themselves something that is in limited supply—for example water, food, mates or territory. This competition can take many forms: it can be direct or indirect, it can be between animals within a single species, and it can be between animals of different species. The simplest concept is probably direct competition between members of the same species. When one animal drives off or otherwise directly prevents another animal from gaining a resource, it is called ‘interference competition.’ A clear example of this would be our male elk or caribou fighting for mates in the fall: the winning elk directly prevents the loser from mating with any of the females he’s managed to gather into a harem. Another example could be a bear chasing another bear away from a prime berry patch. 

Two big bull caribou competing for mates: the winner’s genes will survive to the next generation! // Mark Bradley

Running interference

I witnessed a pretty cool example of interference competition one day at Lac Beauvert. I was strolling along the shore near the Queen’s cabin, camera in hand, when I was suddenly confronted with an entire family of Common Mergansers (a fish-eating duck, common in Jasper). They stubbornly refused to yield the trail, much to my surprise. On the lake I could see a Common Loon, patrolling close to shore with his head down, looking very sinister. When one of the Merganser chicks ventured back into the water, the Loon immediately drove him back to shore. Because Loons and Mergansers eat the same prey (fish, leeches and other small aquatic animals), this Loon was interfering with the Merganser’s ability to eat any of his dinner! When I got home, I did a little research and discovered that Loons are known for being very aggressive on their breeding ponds. They will kill other waterfowl, and even other loons, to protect them.

This Common Loon (above) was indulging in a little intraspecific interference competition with these Common Mergansers at Lac Beauvert.
Mark Bradley – Boreal Nature Photography

Giving it 110 percent  

Not all competition is so aggressive or overt. Exploitation competition is when one animal deprives a second animal of a resource simply by consuming the resources itself. Think of it as when one bear eats all the crab-apples in your backyard, those apples are no longer there for another bear to eat (by the way, you ought to cut that tree down… let the bears compete outside of town). In this case, things like making the right decisions about where to look for food, and efficiency in hunting or gathering, are the animal’s main goals. An animal that expends less energy gathering the same amount of food will have more energy for bearing and raising young.

Grizzly bear eating Saskatoon berries. Jasper National Park, Alberta, Canada. // Mark Bradley
Black bears can be in “exploitation competition” with grizzly bears. // Mark Bradley

Over in the bird kingdom, songbirds will compete for territories and advertise their victory via their distinctive songs. Far from being a melodious cry of joy, bird song is more likely to translate to something like: “Flap off! This is my willow bush, and don’t even think of breeding this female!”

There’s no ‘i’ in team (but there is in evolution)

There’s yet another distinction to be made; competition can be between individuals of different species. This is known as interspecific competition. Competition between individuals of the same species is known as intraspecific competition. Of the two types, the strongest competition often occurs within a species. After all, if you’re a wolf, your fellow wolves will be looking for exactly the same resources you are. Members of another species will have slightly different requirements, and may therefore be weaker competition. In fact seeing two related species instead of one may just be a demonstration of competitions past.

Think this Song Sparrow is pouring his heart out to his one true love? Maybe a little, but mostly it’s “Stay away from my territory and mate!” // Mark Bradley

Look at coyotes and wolves for example. Between one and two millions years ago, they were the same wolf-like species (Canis lepophagus, which lived in North America). Somewhere along the way, some populations of Canis lepophagus started doing different things—perhaps some started preying on smaller animals, while others concentrated on larger animals. By doing this, the small prey eaters no longer had to compete directly with the big prey eaters. After many millennia, the populations became so different that they would no longer interbreed and eventually, they had become today’s coyotes and wolves. This is called adaptive radiation, and it was the avoidance of competition that drove it.

A coyote patrolling his territory, Jasper National Park. // Mark Bradley
This coyote (above) generally preys on smaller animals than this wolf (below). There’s no way a coyote could ever take down a moose. A couple of million years ago, there was only one wolf-like animal. // Mark Bradley

One shift at a time

There’s actually a third type of competition that we covered in a previous article on caribou – ‘apparent competition’. This is when two or more prey species share a predator. In our case, both caribou and white-tailed deer are preyed upon by wolves. The presence of more deer results in more wolves, and those abundant wolves then take down even more caribou. Apparent competition has been demonstrated several times on island ecosystems. An island with a single prey/single predator situation is stable because the predator can never eliminate the prey (because the predators start starving when the prey gets too scarce). But when people arrive and add a second prey species (often rats), then the predators can increase to higher numbers and the original prey species is wiped out. The Jasper situation is considerably more complicated, because there are several predators and several prey species, but apparent competition is still thought to be the major reason for caribou decline.

Although they have very different lifestyles, caribou (above) and white-tailed deer (below), share a common predator, resulting in apparent competition. // Mark Bradley

There’s always next year

Competition in nature doesn’t lead to trophies or product endorsements, but can lead to populations being better adapted to their environments. It can also drive other populations to extinction, and is part of the reason for the biodiversity we see today. Now if only the Raptors can stay healthy and get back into the playoffs next year…


Mark Bradley // info@thejasperlocal.com

Articles You May LIke ›
Next step, caribou: Breeding facility ready for first residents
Environment
Next step, caribou: Breeding facility ready for first residents
Bob Covey 
Friday, January 10, 2025
Staff at Jasper’s caribou breeding facility are gearing up to officially welcome its first animals. The 2024 Jasper Wildfire burned some of the $38 mi...
this is a test
Glutton for punishment: will poor Alberta policy doom our wolverines?
Alberta Politics
Glutton for punishment: will poor Alberta policy doom our wolverines?
Mark Bradley 
Friday, December 6, 2024
The wolverine is a reclusive, mysterious animal that is rarely seen by humans. I t’s scientific name is Gulo gulo, which translates to ‘glutton’ or ‘I...
this is a test
Emerging from the ashes: what nature can teach us about rebuilding
Community
Emerging from the ashes: what nature can teach us about rebuilding
Mark Bradley 
Monday, September 16, 2024
Upheaval and change One of the most successful TV shows of the past several years has been Succession, a darkly funny drama about an exceptionally dys...
this is a test
The cycle continues: Wildfire and wildlife
Environment
The cycle continues: Wildfire and wildlife
Mark Bradley 
Wednesday, August 7, 2024
While some animals will die in a fire, most do not. To varying degrees, species have adapted to fires. Biologist and Jasper Local contributor Mark Bra...
this is a test
Most Read ›
Men’s Shed constructing community
Community
Men’s Shed constructing community
Bob Covey 
Tuesday, May 6, 2025
Connection, camaraderie, community: Grand Opening May 10 A new movement is building in Jasper. Since February 6, the local chapter of Men’s Shed Canad...
this is a test
Neophyte author pens fantastical journey in familiar setting
Arts & Culture
Neophyte author pens fantastical journey in familiar setting
Bob Covey 
Saturday, May 3, 2025
The playful bending of personal knowledge, documented history and mythology—kindled from the stories of First Nations cultures he has deep reverence a...
this is a test
Latest ›
GYPSD confirms new superintendent
Community
GYPSD confirms new superintendent
Bob Covey 
Tuesday, April 15, 2025
The Grande Yellowhead Public School Division is welcoming a new, home-grown educator into the division’s top leadership position. Starting July 1, Hin...
this is a test
Jasper Community Team hires new ED, partnering with foundation
Community
Jasper Community Team hires new ED, partnering with foundation
Bob Covey 
Thursday, April 10, 2025
The Jasper Community Team Society has boosted its capacity to assist local residents. The trusted community organization, which has received more than...
this is a test
Pour one out: Remembering some of Jasper’s favourite restaurants
Business
Pour one out: Remembering some of Jasper’s favourite restaurants
Bob Covey 
Monday, April 7, 2025
This piece was originally published in the February issue of The Tomato Food and Drink magazine Nine months after wildfire devastated Jasper, 86-ing a...
this is a test
How to celebrate Pride like a local
Arts & Culture
How to celebrate Pride like a local
Bob Covey 
Friday, April 4, 2025
Local pride is flying high in anticipation of the annual Jasper Pride and Ski Festival. As it’s done for 16 years now, the festival is once again flau...
this is a test

NEXT ARTICLE

Pursuit to purchase SkyTram for $25M

Business, Community, News, Peaks & Valleys

Most Read ›
Men’s Shed constructing community
Community
Men’s Shed constructing community
Bob Covey 
Tuesday, May 6, 2025
Connection, camaraderie, community: Grand Opening May 10 A new movement is building in Jasper. Since February 6, the local chapter of Men’s Shed Canad...
this is a test
Neophyte author pens fantastical journey in familiar setting
Arts & Culture
Neophyte author pens fantastical journey in familiar setting
Bob Covey 
Saturday, May 3, 2025
The playful bending of personal knowledge, documented history and mythology—kindled from the stories of First Nations cultures he has deep reverence a...
this is a test
Latest ›
Men’s Shed constructing community
Community
Men’s Shed constructing community
Bob Covey 
Tuesday, May 6, 2025
Connection, camaraderie, community: Grand Opening May 10 A new movement is building in Jasper. Since February 6, the local chapter of Men’s Shed Canad...
this is a test
Neophyte author pens fantastical journey in familiar setting
Arts & Culture
Neophyte author pens fantastical journey in familiar setting
Bob Covey 
Saturday, May 3, 2025
The playful bending of personal knowledge, documented history and mythology—kindled from the stories of First Nations cultures he has deep reverence a...
this is a test
Opinion: Forget party politics. Vote for local representation
Alberta Politics
Opinion: Forget party politics. Vote for local representation
Bob Covey 
Friday, April 25, 2025
For the first time in decades, Yellowhead has a real race on its hands Pundits and prognosticators are all saying it: this federal election is the mos...
this is a test
Royal rumbling: 10 burgers, two winners, zero regrets
Local Dining
Royal rumbling: 10 burgers, two winners, zero regrets
Wednesday, April 23, 2025
Indulge your senses and support Jasper at the 2025 Taste of Spring Festival Ding ding ding! Let’s get ready for your stomach to RUMBLE! Spring is in t...
this is a test
This site complies with Jasper requirements
Contact us
Privacy Policy
Advertise With Us
About The Jasper Local
Accessibility Policy
Support

Follow Us

Advertise with us

Measurable, targeted, local. Email example@thejasperlocal.com

ePaper
coogle_play
app_store

© Copyright The Jasper Local