logo
  • News
    • Community
    • Local Government
    • Sports
    • Alberta Politics
    • Opinion
    • Obituaries
  • Jasper Builds
  • Peaks & Valleys
    • Wildlife
    • Hiking and Climbing
    • Biking
    • Fishing
    • Snow Sports
  • Culture
    • Jasper Arts & Culture
    • Local Dining
    • Local Literature
  • Jasper History
  • Support
    • News
      • Community
      • Local Government
      • Sports
      • Alberta Politics
      • Opinion
      • Obituaries
    • Jasper Builds
    • Peaks & Valleys
      • Wildlife
      • Hiking and Climbing
      • Biking
      • Fishing
      • Snow Sports
    • Culture
      • Jasper Arts & Culture
      • Local Dining
      • Local Literature
    • Jasper History
    • Support
Comment: Council should start budget with needs, rather than numbers
Alberta Politics, News, Opinion
By Bob Covey
Tuesday, November 3, 2020
Comment: Council should start budget with needs, rather than numbers

It’s municipal budget time and 2021 looks like it’s going to be a doozy.

We knew this was coming. After council made big cuts to last year’s budget in order to cushion the blow to Jasper ratepayers’ wallets in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, there was going to be no other way out of the hole than to crawl right back up the way we came.

Understandably, council doesn’t like the optics of having to pass a 20 or 30 per cent increase over 2020 figures, but however you choose to look at it, $9 million, the ask from staff to put in a “best practices” budget, is a lot of money.

It may be that some relief will be felt as administration figures out what costs will be covered by the recent federal and provincial Municipal Operating Support Transfer (MOST) funding, relief money given to municipalities dealing with pandemic-associated expenses. But by and large, just like every other municipality and city in Alberta, we’re on the hook for regular operating costs.

Unlike most other towns and cities, however, Jasper is going about its financial planning process upside-down. 

Instead of municipal managers presenting their operational budget and the associated sticker price, they’re first asking council what sort of number they’re comfortable with, with the intention of designing their services around that number. Think of it like going into a car dealership with a maximum dollar amount one is willing to spend, then telling the salesperson you need a vehicle that tailors to that figure. You’d be setting yourself up to get hosed!

Municipalities, like cars, need regular maintenance. Things inevitably come up. If your brakes start to squeal and you didn’t budget for new pads and rotors, then what? The calipers wear out and you hit the ditch, that’s what!

Is it not more prudent to take a look at your transportation needs and create your budget from there? 

How can councillors pretend to know the ability of local residents to pay their taxes? Of course ratepayers want municipal operations to be as efficient as possible, but that doesn’t mean we want council to project their concerns onto our capacity to pay. This is what happened last time around when councillors decided on that nice, round figure in the wake of the pandemic. 

That $7,000,000 tax requisition might look slick on paper, and it might have made officials feel better to know they saved homeowners a few hundred bucks, but when it comes down to it, it’s a completely arbitrary figure. Not to mention that the hotels whose money they were so bent on saving were full all summer and local landlords—as well as every other Canadian with a pulse—qualified for emergency subsidies.

Instead of building an operational budget starting from another arbitrary number, why not have staff create a budget to reflect the services required to operate the municipality? Then you can debate the finer points of what constituents are telling you they want and need, instead of scrutinizing every toilet brush and oil change.

Jasper councillors have expressed their queasiness with the proposed budget figures (Council staring down steep budget hikes, November 1).

Sorry gang, but you made this bed. Now it’s time to lay in it. Considering the pressure it’s going to put on local ratepayers, hopefully you can get some sleep.


Bob Covey // bob@thejasperlocal.com

Articles You May LIke ›
Mold discovery prompts possible $250,000 in Activity Centre repairs
Local Government
Mold discovery prompts possible $250,000 in Activity Centre repairs
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Wednesday, October 28, 2026
Jasper council has approved up to $250,000 from reserves for emergency repairs at the Activity Centre after mold and material deterioration were disco...
this is a test
Jasper weighs transit expansion, including Marmot Basin route
Business
Jasper weighs transit expansion, including Marmot Basin route
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Tuesday, October 13, 2026
Jasper could introduce winter bus service to Marmot Basin in November 2027 as part of a proposed five-year transit expansion plan that would more than...
this is a test
Jasper adopts more stringent privacy rules
Alberta Politics
Jasper adopts more stringent privacy rules
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Tuesday, October 6, 2026
"It's a good example of how provincial rules and regulations increase the cost of doing business for municipalities." The Municipality of Jasper has a...
this is a test
Council weighs $42K price tag for future Canada Day
Community
Council weighs $42K price tag for future Canada Day
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Thursday, September 10, 2026
The amounts have been referred to the 2027 budget discussions but have not been approved Editor's note: this story has been edited for clarity after i...
this is a test
Most Read ›
Jasper committee backs parking reduction for 22-unit apartment building
Jasper Builds
Jasper committee backs parking reduction for 22-unit apartment building
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Monday, November 16, 2026
Committee chair Wendy Hall: "This isn't about how many vehicles we can accommodate on a property. It's about how many people we can accommodate in our...
this is a test
Jasper’s Stand Easy was built the hard way
Community
Jasper’s Stand Easy was built the hard way
John Wilmshurst, freelance contributor 
Friday, November 13, 2026
Stand easy! Not yet standing easy during Remembrance Day services in Jasper in 2025. // Bob Covey In the menu of commands given on the Canadian Armed ...
this is a test
Jasper to seek public feedback on Indigenous Relations Strategy
Local Government
Jasper to seek public feedback on Indigenous Relations Strategy
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
The Municipality of Jasper will seek public feedback on a draft strategy outlining how it plans to advance its ongoing commitment to truth and reconci...
this is a test
Rebuild Jasper Run aims to bring runners, visitors back to town
Community
Rebuild Jasper Run aims to bring runners, visitors back to town
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Hundreds of athletes will go the extra mile for Jasper on November 28. The Rebuild Jasper Run is inviting runners to take part in a late-season event ...
this is a test
Latest ›
Jasper-raised lawyer continues serving Alberta clients from B.C.
Business
Jasper-raised lawyer continues serving Alberta clients from B.C.
Thursday, October 29, 2026
Sponsored content Barrister Jessica Reed remains licensed in Alberta, offering estate administration and business law services to clients in Jasper an...
this is a test
Hinton pushes for continued funding of wildfire team
Alberta Politics
Hinton pushes for continued funding of wildfire team
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Wednesday, October 28, 2026
Hinton is urging the Alberta government to commit to continued funding for its specialized wildfire team before the program’s current funding expires ...
this is a test
‘Forever our teammates’: Bearcats honour Hills and Peacock
Community
‘Forever our teammates’: Bearcats honour Hills and Peacock
Tuesday, October 27, 2026
The Jasper U18 Bearcats opened their 2026-27 home season Saturday with a moving tribute to Danica Hills and Kayla Peacock, two young teammates who pas...
this is a test
Nearly half of Jasper Parks Canada workforce affected by job-cut process
Community
Nearly half of Jasper Parks Canada workforce affected by job-cut process
Monday, October 26, 2026
208 Jasper Field Unit employees identified as affected as Parks Canada plans to cut about 500 full-time-equivalent positions nationally Nearly half of...
this is a test

NEXT ARTICLE

Reality bites: council staring down big budget hikes

Alberta Politics, News

Most Read ›
Jasper committee backs parking reduction for 22-unit apartment building
Jasper Builds
Jasper committee backs parking reduction for 22-unit apartment building
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Monday, November 16, 2026
Committee chair Wendy Hall: "This isn't about how many vehicles we can accommodate on a property. It's about how many people we can accommodate in our...
this is a test
Jasper’s Stand Easy was built the hard way
Community
Jasper’s Stand Easy was built the hard way
John Wilmshurst, freelance contributor 
Friday, November 13, 2026
Stand easy! Not yet standing easy during Remembrance Day services in Jasper in 2025. // Bob Covey In the menu of commands given on the Canadian Armed ...
this is a test
Jasper to seek public feedback on Indigenous Relations Strategy
Local Government
Jasper to seek public feedback on Indigenous Relations Strategy
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
The Municipality of Jasper will seek public feedback on a draft strategy outlining how it plans to advance its ongoing commitment to truth and reconci...
this is a test
Rebuild Jasper Run aims to bring runners, visitors back to town
Community
Rebuild Jasper Run aims to bring runners, visitors back to town
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Hundreds of athletes will go the extra mile for Jasper on November 28. The Rebuild Jasper Run is inviting runners to take part in a late-season event ...
this is a test
Latest ›
Rebuild Jasper Run aims to bring runners, visitors back to town
Community
Rebuild Jasper Run aims to bring runners, visitors back to town
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Hundreds of athletes will go the extra mile for Jasper on November 28. The Rebuild Jasper Run is inviting runners to take part in a late-season event ...
this is a test
Jasper to seek public feedback on Indigenous Relations Strategy
Local Government
Jasper to seek public feedback on Indigenous Relations Strategy
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
The Municipality of Jasper will seek public feedback on a draft strategy outlining how it plans to advance its ongoing commitment to truth and reconci...
this is a test
Jasper committee backs parking reduction for 22-unit apartment building
Jasper Builds
Jasper committee backs parking reduction for 22-unit apartment building
Peter Shokeir, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter 
Monday, November 16, 2026
Committee chair Wendy Hall: "This isn't about how many vehicles we can accommodate on a property. It's about how many people we can accommodate in our...
this is a test
Jasper’s Stand Easy was built the hard way
Community
Jasper’s Stand Easy was built the hard way
John Wilmshurst, freelance contributor 
Friday, November 13, 2026
Stand easy! Not yet standing easy during Remembrance Day services in Jasper in 2025. // Bob Covey In the menu of commands given on the Canadian Armed ...
this is a test
This site complies with Jasper requirements
Contact us
Privacy Policy
Advertise With Us
About The Jasper Local
Accessibility Policy
Support

Follow Us

Advertise with us

Measurable, targeted, local. Email example@thejasperlocal.com

ePaper
coogle_play
app_store

© Copyright The Jasper Local